Thirty years of hurt (and eleven years of writing about it) …


Every September, as the melt season on the Greenland ice sheet fizzles out, I and my colleague Martin Stendel do the same thing: we sit down with a year’s worth of daily surface mass balance maps and weather charts from the Polar Portal, work out how the ice sheet fared, and write it up as a guest post for Carbon Brief. Our latest one, covering September 2025 to August 2026 has just appeared over there (yes it’s a little late, we have a lot on right now).

This year’s headline is one I’d rather not be celebrating: 2025-26 was the 30th consecutive year that Greenland lost more ice than it gained. The last year the ice sheet ended in the black was 1996. Even in a year with a cool, cloudy June, a late start to the melt season, and an above-average snowfall budget, it still lost around 135bn tonnes of ice.

The total mass budget of the Greenland ice sheet showing components from the surface, basal and marine budgets.


It struck me, reading back through copy number eleven, that we’ve now been doing this annual health check for over a decade, (we have been doing the famous Carbon Brief pub quiz for almost as long). And I think it’s time to look back and draw a few longer term lessons beyond the single year reports.

Why do we write them at all?

The honest answer is that a single year tells you almost nothing. In 2017 we reported a year where Greenland probably almost gained a small amount of ice — a one-year blip, thanks mostly to heavy snow delivered by the remnants of Hurricane Nicole from the Gulf of Mexico (weather is a long distance phenomenon, and Greenland gets its winter snow from some surprising places). In 2019 the ice sheet lost 329 Gigatonnes after a dry winter and a hot summer. In 2022 and 2024 it lost barely 80 Gigatonnes each. The weather in any given year can swing the budget by hundreds of Gigatonnes.

So while the annual posts are really about that specific year, they’re also a ritual: an agreed moment to check the patient’s pulse and write it down, in the same way, every year, so the numbers can be compared over the longer term. The point of the series is the series.


The baseline has shifted:

In 2021 I noted something that has stuck with me: that year’s surface mass balance, about 396 Gigatonnes, was thoroughly average for the current climate — but in the late 1990s the same number would have been one of the very lowest years on record. What counts as “normal” for Greenland now would have been an alarming outlier when I started. Shifting baseline as the biologists call it is real, but also for the physical climate system: we keep having to re-define “normal”, and in the case of mass budget it seems it is mostly downwards, but we also have to look back and remind ourselves regularly what normal was, back in the day.

When I was a child growing up in England, butterflies were common in our garden, our cars were often covered in dead insects, a hot summer day was 25C (very rarely 30C) and vast rivers of ice came plunging off alpine mountains. None of those things are true anymore.

The Greenland ice sheet is still a vast amount of frozen water, and it will take a very long time indeed for that to change, but the point of our annual health check is to detect, are there important changes in the stability of the patient?

Now for the obligatory small print warning: A healthy surface is not necessarily a healthy ice sheet. Every year, the surface mass balance defined as the snowfall in and the meltwater runoff (that is surface melt but minus any refrozen or retained in the surface snowpack)  out, just like in a bank account has been positive. Often comfortably above average. So far so good. 

But then every year for thirty years, the ice sheet has still shrunk, because the losses at the edges (icebergs calving, warm seawater melting glacier fronts) have quietly exceeded the surplus. I have lost count of the years where the headline was “good snow year, we still lost ice” including this year, where for example the Petermann glacier calved off a 76 km² ice island in early August regardless of the mild summer.

The Peterman Glacier prior to calving in April.

The surface is my own specialty, and I’m very fond of it, but it isn’t where most of the loss is coming from yet.

Through all of the series though, we can discern some consistent patterns. A dry winter plus a hot summer is the disaster recipe: as it was in 2019. A cool, snowy June acts like a shiny protective blanket and can rescue a mediocre year: 2021, 2023 and again this year. And remarkably often, while Europe and North America swelter in heatwaves, Greenland sits on the cool, wet side of the same stuck jet stream pattern. In 2018, 2023 and again in 2026 the same blocked “Omega” weather that baked Europe left Greenland comparatively damp and comfortable. The same pattern shifted by just half a wavelength in the atmosphere either way, and we’d be reporting record melt in Greenland instead.

Even the “nothing happened” years have been hiding things. In 2016 the year looked textbook average, until an April heatwave produced the earliest melt event on record, followed three months later by a new *cold* record in July. Average years, it turns out, are rarely average; you just have to look closely enough. (That year also taught me something about my own work: when we upgraded the DMI model, “average 2016” turned out to have been a rather low, unusual year. The instruments improve too.)

Taking the long view..

Earlier this year also saw publication of a big review I’m a (very minor!) co-author on, led by Prof. Edward Hanna at University of Lincoln, which synthesises everything we know about Greenland surface melt from 1500 CE out to 2200 covering data from ice cores, the satellite era and projections. It makes the same point out eleven annual posts have been circling around, but with 500 years of evidence instead of a decade: the year-to-year wobbles sum up to a trend that only points one way, and melt  is now visibly in the driver’s seat.


Thirty years is also a meaningful number for a different reason: it’s the length of a “climate normal” period the span climatologists use to separate a genuine shift in climate from natural variability. With 30 consecutive years of losses, warm years, cold years, snowy years, altogether we can now say confidently that what we’ve been writing in these annual posts isn’t weather any more. It’s climate change.

The long view: Hanna, E., Box, J.E., Fettweis, X., van den Broeke, M.R., Wake, L., Luu, L., Maddison, J., Mote, T., Mottram, R., Noël, B., Preece, J., Topál, D., Trusel, L. et al. Past, present and future Greenland Ice Sheet surface melt, 1500–2200 CE. Nature Reviews Earth & Environment, 7, 511–527 (2026) doi:10.1038/s43017-026-00800-3

The annual summaries are built on the daily monitoring at the Polar Portal supported by the Danish Meteorological Institute (through NCKF) and ESA’s Climate Change Initiative.

As always, questions and comments welcome below or on Mastodon

Antarctic snows

Here’s a sentence I have been promising to write on this blog since at least March this year: Antarctica has been gaining ice since 2020. Not losing, gaining. Only 68 gigatonnes a year admittedly, actually a mere drop in the ocean, (or should that be crystal in the ice sheet?), given the vast size of the place, but an (almost) new paper that I worked on, led by the excellent Marlen Kolbe, explains why.

From Kolbe et al., 2026 Black: Monthly cumulative GMB anomalies from April 2002 to December 2024, based on GRACE (with respect to the mass as of 2011-01-01 before being subtracted from the GMB anomaly in April 2002 to show the changes since the mission launch). Dotted: Monthly cumulative SMB anomalies based on ERA5 from April 2002 to April 2025 (ERA5), December 2024 (HCLIM43) and December 2023 (RACMO2.4p), all with respect to the 1995-2010 mean, before subtracting their SMB from April 2002 (as for GRACE). Light straight solid lines indicate linear trend slopes from 2003 to 2019, and 2020 to 2024 (2023 for RACMO2.4p), with trends printed in the respective colour (all trend slopes are significant with p < 0.05). The small change in the grey line’s angle around 2017 reflects the 1-year GRACE – GRACE-FO gap. Red time series: Grounding line discharge from8 based on bed topography and velocity measurements from 1996 through to July 2024

First, the background. For most of this century, the Antarctic Ice Sheet has been losing mass at a pretty steady rate of around 100 Gigatonnes a year, pushing up global sea levels a small amount (About one third of a millimetre per year in fact, a little less than half the Greenland contribution for example). Antarctica is by far the biggest potential contributor to future sea level rise, so this is the number we all watch rather closely, as we also discussed the other week when the IMBIE paper came out. Then, around 2016, the satellites started telling us something odd: the losses were slowing down. And by 2020, the whole continent had swung into a small but definitely positive net gain — even though the ice flowing out to sea from West Antarctica’s glaciers kept accelerating throughout (the red curve in the figure above and the red areas in the discharge maps below).

Maps show linear trends of GMB (c, f), SMB (d, g), and discharge (e, h) per basin for two time periods. Basins are greyed out where the trend is not significant (p < 0.05). 

So what was going on? The answer, it turns out, is snow. Rather a lot of it in fact, falling mostly in East Antarctica, but also in other events over the peninsula and in West Antarctica. But what was driving those enhanced snowfalls? The blue bits in the picture above show regions where there is an increase in snowfall

In what is either an incredible coincidence, or somehow a related process, at the same time the sea ice around Antarctica started to decline, big time:

Rank of monthly sea-ice extent – Southern Hemisphere from our colleagues at EUMETSAT’s OSISAF facility

This was also an idea we explored in our Greenlandification paper, so my initial suspicion was that the loss of sea ice around the continent allowed more snow to reach the coast, both because more open water meant more evaporation from the sea, but also because less was lost over the sea ice. And a first sight of the statistics seems to support that.

From Kolbe et al., 2026 a Seasonal correlations of basin-wide SMB and adjacent ocean-basin SIC for summer (DJF), autumn (MAM), winter (JJA), and spring (SON). The basins are shown in (b), where the transparent land areas represent the region where SMB anomalies are summed (excluding ice shelves), and correlated to the respective adjacent ocean basins. WS Weddell Sea, IND Indian Ocean, WP West Pacific, RS Ross sea, AMU Amundsen sea, BEL Bellingshausen sea. Boxes without numbers indicate insignificant correlations (p ≥ 0.05)

But it’s not very convincing – those correlation values are pretty low in most cases and of course, as we all know, correlation doesn’t really prove causality. So given we have a model, we could actually do something kind of cool, and run some experiments. In this case we added additional sea ice and we took sea ice away. And we showed that indeed there is a *small* effect of sea ice on the snow that reaches the continent.

From Kolbe et al., 2026 Mean Sea ice concentration from June 2021 to July 2022 under (a) control conditions (CTRL), b enhanced sea ice (exICE), and c no sea ice (noICE) scenarios. d Total accumulated precipitation from June 2021 to July 2022 in the control simulation, and that of the noICE (e) and exICE (f) experiments minus the control run. Numbers beneath the plots give the total amount (or difference from) for the grounded ice sheet (AIS) and including ice shelves (AIS + IS). In d blue circles mark regions exceeding 6000 mm with the maximum value shown in the blue rectangle. In c, d, green circles mark regions exceeding 1500 mm and orange circles mark regions below −1000 mm with min/max values per plot are shown in the upper rectangles; 

But there is also likely another explanation..

Rivers in the sky

The snow delivery service comes in the form of atmospheric rivers. As the name indicates these aren’t rivers of water on the ground but long, narrow filaments of water vapour in the atmosphere, and they can carry astonishing amounts of moisture from the subtropics all the way to the Antarctic coast. When one of these slams into the steep edge of the ice sheet, all that moisture falls out as snow.

Think of them as the sky’s equivalent of a shower: most days the atmosphere delivers very little moisture or a relatively small even flow for a quick wash, but occasionally the power shower comes on and a single event dumps a month or even a year’s worth of snow in a day or two.

Atmospheric rivers originate from the southern Pacific Ocean and transport heat and moisture to the Antarctic Peninsula. Satellite image: Jonathan Wille/MODIS/NASA From the Polar Journal

Marlen’s analysis showed that from 2020 onwards, atmospheric rivers reaching Antarctica became both more frequent and more intense, helped along by stronger westerly winds (an effect of the southern annular mode, known as SAM to friends) and changes in the sea ice around the coast. East Antarctica got hammered with exceptional snowfall in 2022 in particular especially in Queen Maud Land and Wilkes Land and that extra snowfall more than compensated for the (still increasing!) ice loss from West Antarctica.

This is the surface mass balance doing its thing: SMB is a two-way term, with snowfall adding mass and melt and runoff removing it. In Antarctica there is very little surface melt and even less runoff so a few enormous snowfall years can push the whole continent’s ledger into the black, even while the dynamic term, what we call ice discharge in the paper, which only ever removes mass, has been accelerating.

So is this good news?

I’m afraid not, or at least, not necessarily.

We don’t know yet whether this gain is a temporary blip or a lasting feature of a warmer world. Atmospheric rivers are driven by weather patterns reaching Antarctica from the tropics and mid-latitudes, and the patterns that control them can shift as another recent paper (that came out after ours) also pointed out. A few years with fewer atmospheric rivers could easily tip the mass budget back to losses, even larger ones than before given the acceleration of ice lost in West Antarctica.

The satellite debt

None of this would be known without the GRACE satellites (and the successor, GRACE-FO), which measure changes in Earth’s gravity field and can effectively weigh an ice sheet from orbit. It never ceases to amaze me that we can now effectively put the Antarctic Ice Sheet on a bathroom scale, as a friend of mine once commented – we’re really living in the future with this stuff. The work was part-funded through ESA’s Climate Change Initiative (of which more in a later post), which has quietly built some of the most valuable long-term climate datasets we have, this study is one more reason they deserve support. Modelling was conducted in the course of our Horizon Europe OCEAN ICE project that is now sadly coming to an end (more of that anon).

The paper

Full credit to the immensely productive Marlen Kolbe, who led the work based on ideas we had while she was a visiting PhD student, and to my ace colleague Abraham Torres Alavez who ran the multiple experiments as well as to all my co-authors.

Kolbe, M., Torres Alavez, J.A., Mottram, R., et al. (2026). Atmospheric rivers and winter sea ice drive recent reversal in Antarctic ice mass loss. Communications Earth & Environment, 7, 255. doi:10.1038/s43247-026-03242-3

As always, questions, corrections and speculations welcome in the comments here, or find me on mastodon at @ruth_mottram.